Class number:
052
Class Date:
5/3/08
Judge:
Vance Christie
Judging Contest Winners:
Under 15: CrazySuey, slowewe
15-18: cwsmith, Millie, ncbuckhunter,
shropgirl1
Over 18: classic1112,
dockrock, kateandsun, melkylene, mm, PAFFAStarFarmer07, timatpa, woolpuller |
Official Placing:
1, 3, 4, 2
Cuts: 2, 2, 2
I have a hard time finding
a clear winner or loser in this class, and feel you can easily justify
any placing. Therefore the cuts will be 2-2-2, and I am going to place
them 1, 3, 4, 2. |
First Place: 1
Entry number:
258
Exhibitor:
Timatpa
State: PA
Sheep
name/number: Prince
Breed:
Suffolk/Hampshire |
|
1 appears to be the most
fault-free lamb in the class. The picture angles make it somewhat
difficult to get the same view on him, however I predict that he is the
thickest of the 4. I'll be the first to admit he may be a little
lacking as far as depth of twist and lower leg. Yet he appears to be
neater through is front end, tucked better through the floor of his
chest and better balanced from front to rear. In addition he spreads
the most width and dimension down his top.
|
Second Place: 3
Entry number:
262
Exhibitor:
JbarG
State: OH
Sheep
name/number: 8-06
Breed:
Suffolk X |
|
Here is the lamb I would
like to start with if it were not for his deeper chest and drop in his
dock. Certainly 3 is more expressive in his muscle and powerful through
the stifle and inner thigh. However he is more extreme in his rib and
drops in his pin placement slightly. Still there is simply more product
in him vs. the ewe lamb. He reads to have more shape of rack and
fullness of loin, and most importantly is bigger hipped and better
maintains that thickness to his lower leg.
|
Third Place: 4
Entry number:
264
|
|
The ewe lamb is potentially
the best designed lamb in class. Unfortunately she is the most
juvenile and appears to be narrower based from front to rear compared to
her contemporaries. Still I read her as a higher quality sheep than 2
that should only get better with age and feed. I am particularly
impressed with the way her neck, shoulder and rib tie together compared
to the 3 wethers. As a bonus she has a tremendously long and level hip
for her age and condition.
|
Fourth Place: 2
Entry number:
259 |
|
2 probably has the most
mass and volume, but in reality it is probably due to the fact that he
appears to be the most mature and has a simple size advantage. I read
him as being more plain in his constitution, not showing the true
thickness and expression of muscle we see in the top three. He is also
at a disadvantage due to lacking the condition and bloom that we see in
the younger lambs.
Again a difficult class with lambs that can start or lose the class
depending on your priorities. Good Luck! Eenie Minnie Miny Moe-close!
|
|